CLOUD #2 Personal

I had a disagreement with my parents on of I should buy a used car or spend more money to buy a new car. They wanted me to buy a used car because it is cheaper. I wanted to buy a new car because it would last me longer. I am not sure now if I should buy a car for the quality or for the price. I do not have a large amount of money to spend on a new car, but I need a car that will last a long time.

B: get a car that is cheap
D: buy a used car
A: buy a car that is cheap and will last a long time
Click on the icons on the arrows to see assumptions and injections
C: get a car that will last a long time
D': buy a new car

In order to buy a car that is cheap and will last a long time I must get a car that is cheap and in order to get a car that is cheap I must buy a used car. But, in order to buy a car that is cheap and will last a long time I must also get a car that will last a long time and in order to get a car that will last a long time I must buy a new car. I can't both buy a used car and buy a new car.

RelationAssumption(s)Injection(s)
D-D'I cannot buy both a used car and a new carI can buy a car that has only been lightly used
B-Dused cars cost less than new carsnot all new cars cost more than used cars
C-D'new cars last longer than old carsSome old cars can last a long time if kept in good condition
A-BI do not have a large amount of money Not all cars that are cheap last a long time
A-CI will need to use the car for a long timeNot all cars that last a long time are cheap